Introduction: Selling a Rental Property? Here’s What Landlords Need to Know
Owning rental property in Springfield, MO, and nearby areas like Nixa, Ozark, Republic, and Battlefield can be profitable—but when tenant issues, market conditions, or financial burdens arise, selling may be the best option.
This guide will help landlords navigate the challenges of selling a rental property, whether you’re dealing with problem tenants, tax implications, lease agreements, or financial concerns.
1. Can You Sell a Rental Property with Tenants in Place?
Yes! But the process depends on your tenant’s lease and cooperation level.
Your Options:
- Sell to an Investor (best for occupied rentals; investors buy with tenants in place)
- Wait for Lease Expiration (if tenants aren’t willing to cooperate)
- Negotiate Early Move-Out (offer “cash for keys”)
- Sell to a Homeowner (works best if tenants have a month-to-month lease)
📌 Related Blog: How to Sell a Rental Property with Problem Tenants
2. Selling a Rental Property As-Is: Should You Make Repairs?
If your rental property needs major repairs, you don’t have to renovate before selling. Many landlords sell their properties as-is to avoid costly upgrades.
Pros of Selling As-Is:
✅ Saves time and money ✅ Appeals to investors looking for rental income properties ✅ No need for costly repairs or upgrades
📌 Related Blog: Selling a Rental Property As-Is (No Repairs, No Hassle)
3. Understanding the Tax Implications of Selling a Rental Property
Selling a rental property has tax consequences, including capital gains taxes and depreciation recapture. Knowing your options can help reduce your tax burden.
Key Considerations:
- Capital Gains Tax: Based on how long you’ve owned the property
- Depreciation Recapture: Taxed at 25% on depreciation deductions taken
- 1031 Exchange: Allows tax deferral if reinvesting in another property
📌 Related Blog: Tax Implications of Selling a Rental Property
4. When Is the Best Time to Sell a Rental Property?
Some key signs that it’s time to sell include:
- High maintenance costs & repairs
- Non-paying or problematic tenants
- Rising property taxes and insurance rates
- Shifts in the local housing market
📌 Related Blog: When to Sell a Rental Property in Springfield, MO – 5 Signs It’s Time to Cash Out
5. What If You Need to Evict a Tenant Before Selling?
Evictions can be complicated, but if you’re planning to sell your rental property vacant, you may need to remove tenants first.
Options to Remove Tenants:
- “Cash for Keys” Agreement – Offer tenants money to vacate voluntarily
- Formal Eviction – If tenants won’t leave or are behind on rent
- Sell with Tenants in Place – Some investors prefer occupied properties
📌 Related Blog: Evicting a Tenant Before Selling: Pros & Cons
6. Can You Sell a Rental Property Without Paying Realtor Fees?
Many landlords sell directly to investors or use FSBO (For Sale By Owner) strategies to save on commissions.
Ways to Avoid Realtor Fees:
- Sell to an Investor (fast, cash sales, no fees)
- Sell Off-Market (network with buyers directly)
- Use a Flat-Fee MLS Listing (low-cost agent services)
📌 Related Blog: Selling a Rental Property Without Paying Realtor Fees
7. Selling a Rental Property with a Non-Paying Tenant: What Are Your Options?
If your tenant isn’t paying rent, selling can be challenging, but it’s possible.
Solutions:
- Sell to an Investor (investors buy properties with non-paying tenants)
- Start the Eviction Process (if necessary before closing the sale)
- Negotiate a Move-Out (offer an incentive for them to leave)
📌 Related Blog: Selling a Rental Property with a Non-Paying Tenant
8. How a 1031 Exchange Can Help You Avoid Taxes When Selling a Rental Property
A 1031 exchange allows you to defer capital gains taxes by reinvesting the proceeds into another rental property.
Benefits of a 1031 Exchange:
✅ Defers taxes on capital gains ✅ Allows reinvestment into a better property ✅ Grows your real estate portfolio tax-free
📌 Related Blog: How to Use a 1031 Exchange When Selling a Rental Property
9. Selling a Rental Property During Tax Season: Pros & Cons
Pros:
✅ More serious buyers are active ✅ Year-end tax benefits for investors
Cons:
❌ Tighter financing conditions for buyers ❌ Limited market activity during winter months
📌 Related Blog: Selling a Rental Property During Tax Season – Pros & Cons
10. Inheriting a Rental Property? How to Sell It Fast
Many landlords inherit rental properties but don’t want to manage them. If you need to sell quickly, consider fast-sale options.
📌 Related Blog: Selling an Inherited Rental Property in Springfield, MO – Fast & Stress-Free
11. Selling a Rental Property with a Lease in Place: What You Need to Know
If your rental has an active lease, you can still sell it, but buyers must honor the tenant’s lease.
📌 Related Blog: Selling a Rental Property with a Lease in Place
12. Cash for Keys vs. Eviction: Which is Better for Landlords?
If you need tenants to leave before selling, cash for keys can be a faster, less expensive alternative to eviction.
📌 Related Blog: Cash for Keys vs. Eviction: What’s the Best Option for Landlords?
Final Thoughts: Find the Best Selling Strategy for Your Rental Property
If you’re a landlord in Springfield, MO, selling your rental property doesn’t have to be stressful. Whether you sell to an investor, list on the market, or use a 1031 exchange, knowing your options can help you make the best decision.
Need expert guidance? Explore your selling options today!
👉 Get Your No Obligation Offer Here
Or fill out this quick, easy form to get your offer in 24-48 hours.
If you just want to chat, just give us a call, anytime (417) 414 – 0838
Also stay in touch with all our social media! See what projects we are working on and coming up! Linktree